Erin Gibney’s ‘Wasted Potential’ Hits You Right in the Feels—And You’ll Thank Her for It

Let’s talk about Erin Gibney—the soft-spoken powerhouse who's been slowly and beautifully cracking open her chest and letting us peek straight into her soul. If you've followed her journey, you already know she's never shied away from raw emotion. But with her new single “Wasted Potential”, she’s not just letting us look—she’s handing us the pieces of her heart and saying, “Here. Feel this with me.”

And you will feel it.

Right out the gate, Wasted Potential lands like a slow punch to the stomach. It's a stunning, stripped-down ballad drenched in the kind of honesty that makes you pause mid-drive or mid-scroll and go, wait… she just said what I’ve been too scared to admit. That line alone? It's a universal gut check for anyone who's ever built a future with someone only to have the ground shift beneath their feet.

This isn’t just another heartbreak anthem—it’s a reckoning. Erin isn’t just mourning a relationship here. She’s reckoning with time, identity, direction. It’s that moment in the mirror where you ask yourself, “What was it all for?” And Erin has the guts to not only ask it out loud but to sing it with clarity, grace, and a haunting emotional depth.

She doesn’t sugarcoat it. This isn’t the dreamy optimism of early 20-something love. It’s the ash-and-smoke aftermath that follows. And yet—there’s something oddly hopeful in the ashes. Erin calls Wasted Potential a blessing and a curse, and she’s dead-on. Because once the dust settles, that “wasted” time? It turns out to be something else entirely. Growth. Strength. A clearer view of what you won’t settle for again.

And if anyone gets that, it’s Erin.

Since moving to Nashville in 2017, Erin has been steadily carving out a space for herself in the world of contemporary country—not by chasing trends, but by doing what the greats do: telling the truth. Whether she’s singing about heartbreak (You Made Your Bed), letting go (Exit Signs), or vulnerability (By June), there’s an unmistakable thread that runs through all of her work: authenticity.

Erin isn’t afraid to admit when things hurt, when things didn’t go as planned, or when she’s just figuring it out as she goes. She’s not trying to be the “cool girl” anymore. She’s owning the mess, the healing, the piecing-it-all-back-together part—and that’s what makes her so easy to root for.

Produced by Cameron McClaren and co-written with Alex Angelo, Wasted Potential is gorgeously arranged. It’s country through and through, but with a modern softness that lets Erin’s voice—and the weight of her words—take center stage. Cameron and Alex handle the song with the kind of care it deserves, never overshadowing the story. Instead, they wrap it in a quiet warmth that lets it sting in just the right way.

You get the sense that every person involved in this track knew how special it was.

Erin Gibney’s Wasted Potential is not just a song—it’s a moment. A catharsis. A quiet revolution in a world that constantly pressures us to “move on” or “bounce back” quickly. It invites you to sit in the ache, even if just for a minute. And somehow, in doing so, it helps you breathe again.

So, no—nothing about Erin’s 20s has been wasted. She’s lived, loved, lost, and come back with stories we all recognize in our bones. And if this song is any indication of what’s ahead for her, we’re not just witnessing the rise of a great country artist.

We’re watching a truth-teller come into her power.

Put Wasted Potential on repeat, grab a glass of wine, and let yourself feel it. Erin Gibney isn’t just singing your heartbreak—she’s singing hers, and it’s beautiful, bruised, and absolutely unforgettable.

Follow Erin Gibney